Syracuse Food Guide
Syracuse has been a crossroads of Mediterranean civilisations for nearly three thousand years, and its cuisine reflects every one of them. Greek colonists brought olive oil and wine. Arabs introduced aubergines, almonds, sugar, and the techniques that eventually became gelato and marzipan. Normans added heartier northern European influences. Spanish rulers left behind their love of fried foods and rich pastries. The result is a cuisine of extraordinary depth and variety — rooted in the sea, the volcanic soil of eastern Sicily, and an unbroken tradition of making exceptional food from intensely local ingredients.
This guide covers the essential dishes, street foods, wines, and restaurants of Syracuse, with a focus on what you can actually find on menus when you visit. These aren't museum-piece recipes — they're the living, breathing cuisine of a city that takes its food as seriously as its archaeology.
Essential Dishes
Pasta alla Siracusana
The signature pasta of Syracuse — and one of the few dishes in Sicily that carries a specific city name. Pasta alla Siracusana combines roasted peppers, fried aubergine, ripe tomatoes, anchovies, garlic, capers, black olives, and fresh basil, all tossed through short pasta (usually rigatoni or penne). The result is a dish of extraordinary complexity: sweet from the peppers, savoury from the anchovies, rich from the aubergine, and bright from the tomatoes and basil. Every household and restaurant has its own balance of ingredients, and the debate over the "correct" version is a beloved local argument. The dish epitomises the Arab-Sicilian culinary fusion — aubergine and peppers arriving via North Africa, anchovies from the Ionian Sea, capers from the nearby Aeolian islands. Order it at any trattoria on Ortigia and you'll understand why the Syracusani consider it their masterpiece.
Pesce Fresco — Fresh Fish
Syracuse is, above all, a fishing city. The morning fish market on Ortigia — held daily except Sunday in the streets behind the Temple of Apollo — is one of the great food experiences of Sicily. Fishermen sell the night's catch directly from their crates: swordfish (pesce spada), tuna (tonno), red mullet (triglie), sea bream (orata), octopus (polpo), squid (calamari), prawns (gamberi), and whatever else the Ionian Sea yielded that morning. Restaurants across Ortigia buy from this market and serve the fish within hours. The simplest preparations are often the best: grilled whole fish with lemon and olive oil, raw seafood crudi (Syracuse's version of sashimi, served with a drizzle of local extra-virgin oil), or frittura mista — a mixed fry of small fish and squid eaten with your fingers. The tuna in particular is superb: Sicily has been fishing bluefin tuna for millennia, and the traditional mattanza (tuna harvest) was a defining ritual of coastal Sicilian life.
Granita di Mandorla
Sicilian granita is not a slushy. It's a semi-frozen dessert of extraordinary refinement, made by slowly freezing a flavoured liquid while scraping it repeatedly to create a texture somewhere between sorbet and ice — smooth, crystalline, and intensely flavoured. In Syracuse, the classic flavour is almond (mandorla), made from locally grown almonds that are blanched, ground, and steeped to extract a rich, milky liquid before freezing. The result is subtle, fragrant, and not too sweet — completely different from the artificial almond flavourings found elsewhere. Granita is traditionally a breakfast food in eastern Sicily: served in a glass with a fresh brioche (a soft, dome-shaped roll) for dipping, alongside a strong espresso. The combination of cold, sweet granita with warm, pillowy brioche is one of the great sensory pleasures of Sicilian life. You'll find it at every bar and pasticceria, but the best versions use real almonds rather than commercial pastes.
Arancini
Sicily's most famous street food: deep-fried balls of saffron-tinted rice stuffed with ragù (meat sauce and peas), mozzarella, or other fillings. In Syracuse and eastern Sicily, arancini are typically cone-shaped (arancini al ragù) or round (arancini al burro, filled with ham, mozzarella, and béchamel). The exterior should be shatteringly crisp, the rice layer dense and well-seasoned, and the filling molten. They're sold from fryer-counters at bakeries, bars, and dedicated friggitorie across the city. The best arancini are made fresh throughout the day; avoid any that look like they've been sitting under a heat lamp for hours. Each one is a substantial snack — or two with a salad makes a perfectly respectable lunch.
Cuddura (Cuddureddi)
A traditional Easter bread unique to the Syracuse area, cuddura is a ring-shaped or figure-shaped bread enriched with eggs, sugar, and anise. Whole hard-boiled eggs are baked into the dough, held in place by strips of pastry, creating an edible Easter basket. The shapes vary — doves, baskets, dolls, hearts — and families compete to make the most elaborate versions. The dough itself is lightly sweet and fragrant, meant to be torn apart and shared. Outside Easter season, simpler versions appear as biscotti (twice-baked cookies) flavoured with anise and studded with almonds, sold at bakeries year-round. These everyday cuddureddi are perfect with an afternoon espresso.
Pasta con le Sarde (alla Siracusana Variation)
While pasta con le sarde is more closely associated with Palermo, Syracuse has its own variation that reflects the city's eastern Sicilian identity. The dish combines fresh sardines (or anchovies when sardines aren't available), wild fennel fronds, pine nuts, raisins, saffron, and breadcrumbs toasted in olive oil. The Syracuse version tends to be lighter than the Palermitan original, with more emphasis on the fresh fish and less on the sweet-sour raisin-and-pine-nut balance. Wild fennel grows abundantly along the roadsides and coastlines of southeastern Sicily, and its anise-like flavour is the backbone of the dish. Look for it on menus from autumn through spring, when sardines and wild fennel are both in season.
Cuccìa
A dish intimately associated with the Festa di Santa Lucia on December 13, cuccìa is made from whole wheat berries boiled until tender, then dressed either savoury (with ricotta, olive oil, and pepper) or sweet (with ricotta cream, candied fruit, chocolate chips, and cinnamon). The tradition holds that during a famine in Syracuse, a ship full of grain arrived on Santa Lucia's feast day, and the starving population ate the wheat boiled rather than waiting to mill it into flour. Today, cuccìa is eaten exclusively on December 13, and Syracusan bakeries and homes prepare vast quantities. The sweet version — wheat berries folded into sweetened sheep's-milk ricotta — is the more common dessert preparation, rich and satisfying, tasting of grain, cream, and celebration.
Street Food & Quick Bites
Syracuse's street food scene is centred on Ortigia, particularly around the morning market and the streets near the Ponte Umbertino. Beyond arancini, look for:
Panelle: Thin chickpea-flour fritters, golden-fried and served in a soft roll with a squeeze of lemon. Originally a Palermitan street food, panelle have spread across Sicily and are now found at most Syracusan street-food stalls. The texture should be crisp outside and creamy within.
Sfincione: A thick, spongy Sicilian-style pizza topped with tomato sauce, onions, anchovies, breadcrumbs, and caciocavallo cheese. Unlike Neapolitan pizza, sfincione is soft and bready, more like a focaccia. It's sold by the slice at bakeries and market stalls.
Cannoli: Sicily's most exported dessert, at its best when eaten in Sicily with freshly filled shells. The tubular pastry shell should be crisp and bubbly (not pre-filled, which makes it soggy), the ricotta filling smooth and subtly sweet, and the ends dipped in chopped pistachios or candied orange peel. In Syracuse, the ricotta often comes from sheep raised in the nearby Iblei mountains, giving it a distinctive richness.
Cassata Siciliana: An elaborate cake of sponge, ricotta cream, marzipan, and candied fruit, cassata is the showpiece of Sicilian pasticceria. In Syracuse, it tends to be slightly less ornate than the Palermitan versions but no less delicious. It's traditionally an Easter dessert but available year-round at most pastry shops.
Wine
Moscato di Siracusa DOC
One of the oldest wines in Italy — possibly in the world. Moscato di Siracusa DOC is a sweet, amber dessert wine made from Moscato Bianco grapes grown in the vineyards around Syracuse. The Roman naturalist Pliny the Elder mentioned it in his Natural History (1st century AD), and it was likely produced long before that, possibly by the Greek colonists who founded the city. After centuries of near-extinction, a handful of producers have revived the wine in recent decades. The flavour is intensely aromatic — apricot, honey, orange blossom, and dried herbs — with a sweetness balanced by acidity. It's traditionally served with almond pastries, cannoli, or strong aged cheeses. Production is tiny, so you're more likely to find it at specialist wine bars and restaurants in Syracuse than in shops. Tasting it here, in the vineyards where it has been made for over two millennia, is a remarkable experience.
Nero d'Avola
Sicily's signature red grape, Nero d'Avola takes its name from the town of Avola, just 25 kilometres south of Syracuse. This makes the Syracuse area essentially the ancestral home of Sicily's most important wine variety. At its best, Nero d'Avola produces deeply coloured, full-bodied reds with flavours of dark cherry, plum, spice, and a distinctive earthy warmth. The wines range from easy-drinking everyday bottles to serious, oak-aged cuvées that rival top mainland Italian reds. Several wineries in the Noto-Avola-Syracuse triangle offer tastings and tours — a half-day wine excursion is one of the best day-trip options from Syracuse, combining vineyard visits with lunch at a countryside agriturismo.
Other Local Wines
Beyond Moscato and Nero d'Avola, the Syracuse wine region produces excellent Frappato (a lighter, perfumed red often blended with Nero d'Avola to make Cerasuolo di Vittoria DOCG, Sicily's only DOCG wine), Grillo and Catarratto whites (crisp, mineral, food-friendly), and Nerello Mascalese from the slopes of Mount Etna to the north. Any decent restaurant in Syracuse will have a wine list weighted towards these southeastern Sicilian producers, and you should take advantage: the quality-to-price ratio of Sicilian wine is among the best in Italy.
The Ortigia Fish Market
The Mercato di Ortigia, held every morning except Sunday in the streets behind the Temple of Apollo, is more than a market — it's a performance. Fishermen shout their catches, vendors slice swordfish with theatrical precision, and the air fills with the sharp, clean scent of the sea. The market has occupied this site for centuries, and its location next to the ancient temple is a perfect metaphor for Syracuse itself: the ancient and the everyday, side by side.
Beyond fish, the market sells local produce — blood oranges (in season from December to April), pistachios from Bronte, almonds from Avola, capers from Pantelleria, sundried tomatoes, local cheeses (pecorino, ricotta salata, ragusano), and cured meats. Several stalls sell prepared foods: raw seafood plates, fried fish cones, and sandwiches. It's the ideal place for a late-morning snack before a proper lunch.
The fish market winds down by early afternoon. If you want the full experience — the shouting, the bargaining, the spectacle — arrive between 8:00 and 11:00 AM.
Where to Eat — Restaurants
Don Camillo
The most celebrated restaurant in Syracuse, Don Camillo has been serving refined Sicilian cuisine since the 1990s from a vaulted, stone-walled dining room on one of Ortigia's most elegant streets. The menu is built around the day's market catch: raw preparations (crudi) of exceptional quality, creative pasta dishes that honour tradition while adding contemporary touches, and main courses that showcase the best of the Ionian Sea. The wine list is deep, with particular strength in southeastern Sicilian producers. Chef's tasting menus are available and recommended for a full exploration. Service is polished but warm. Reservations are essential, especially in summer — this is where serious food lovers eat in Syracuse.
Sicilia in Tavola
A much-loved trattoria near Castello Maniace at the southern tip of Ortigia, Sicilia in Tavola serves generous portions of traditional Syracusan cooking at honest prices. The pasta alla Siracusana here is excellent — rich, well-balanced, and made with real intention. Other standouts include spaghetti ai ricci di mare (sea urchin pasta, in season from October to April), grilled swordfish, and a fritto misto of impeccable crispness. The setting is casual — paper tablecloths, a few outdoor tables facing the castle walls — and the atmosphere is cheerfully local. No pretension, just very good food. Arrive early or expect to wait; they don't take reservations and they're popular for good reason.
Osteria da Mariano
Tucked down one of Ortigia's narrowest alleys, Osteria da Mariano is the kind of place you could walk past a dozen times without noticing — which is precisely why it stays good. The menu is short, changes daily, and reflects whatever Mariano found at the market that morning. Expect hand-cut pasta with sardines and wild fennel, seared tuna with caponata, or a simple but perfect insalata di polpo (octopus salad). Portions are generous, prices are modest, and the wine comes in jugs. The dining room seats perhaps 30 people at mismatched tables, and the atmosphere is convivial — strangers end up talking to each other, which is the mark of a genuine Sicilian osteria. Cash only.
Caseificio Borderi
Not a restaurant in any conventional sense, Caseificio Borderi is a tiny cheese shop and deli on the edge of the Ortigia market that has become one of the most famous food stops in Sicily. Owner Andrea Borderi makes sandwiches with the flair of a conductor: each one is a custom composition of local cheeses, cured meats, sundried tomatoes, capers, fresh herbs, and olive oil, assembled with theatrical showmanship and genuine care. The queue can stretch down the street, especially during summer, but it moves fast. Andrea remembers regulars, banters with tourists, and somehow keeps track of dozens of simultaneous orders. A Borderi sandwich, eaten sitting on the harbour wall with a view of the boats, is one of the essential Syracuse food experiences. Expect to pay €5–8 for a sandwich that will fill you completely.
Retroscena Ristorante
Located in the old Jewish quarter of Ortigia, Retroscena brings a more contemporary approach to Syracusan cuisine without losing touch with tradition. The dining room is atmospheric — exposed stone, soft lighting, tasteful artwork — and the menu features dishes like red prawn tartare, risotto with sea urchin and burrata, and slow-cooked pork cheek with a reduction of Nero d'Avola. The wine selection is excellent, with knowledgeable staff who can guide you through the best southeastern Sicilian bottles. It's a good choice for a special evening on Ortigia — sophisticated without being stuffy, creative without being contrived.
What to Drink Beyond Wine
Espresso: Syracuse follows the standard Sicilian espresso tradition — strong, short, and often drunk standing at the bar counter. The local roasters favour a darker roast than you'll find in northern Italy, producing a more intense, slightly bitter cup. Order "un caffè" for a single espresso, "un caffè macchiato" for espresso with a spot of milk, or "un caffè freddo" for a pre-sweetened iced espresso — essential in summer.
Limoncello & Amaro: After-dinner digestivi are taken seriously in Syracuse. Limoncello made from the intensely fragrant lemons that grow across eastern Sicily is a common offering, served ice-cold. Amaro — a bitter herbal liqueur — is even more popular, with local and Sicilian brands (Averna, produced in Caltanissetta, is the most widely available) served neat or over ice. Many restaurants make their own house amaro from foraged herbs and citrus peel.
Seltz, Limone e Sale: A distinctly Catanese/Syracusan summer drink: seltzer water mixed with fresh lemon juice and a pinch of salt, served at bar counters from vintage soda siphons. It's intensely refreshing in the heat, costs almost nothing, and is one of those small, local pleasures that tourist guides rarely mention.
Food Shopping & Souvenirs
If you want to bring Syracuse home with you, the Ortigia market and surrounding shops offer plenty of edible souvenirs. Look for: Mandorla di Avola — the prized almonds from nearby Avola, sold raw, roasted, or as almond paste for making granita at home. Pomodori secchi — sundried tomatoes, often packed in olive oil with capers and herbs. Miele di timo — thyme honey from the Iblei mountains, dark, aromatic, and quite unlike supermarket honey. Olio extra vergine d'oliva — fresh-pressed extra-virgin olive oil from the DOP-designated Monti Iblei region, grassy and peppery, at prices that seem absurdly cheap compared to what the same quality costs abroad. And, of course, bottles of Nero d'Avola and Moscato di Siracusa to drink at home and remember the trip.
← Back to Eco Hotels in Syracuse